Following his Radio 5 Live spot about ID cards last night (see the post below for links and email info), another email from Sean Gabb arrived, to the effect that the programme went well:

… All I had to do this evening was state the main heads of opposition to compulsory identity cards, and then sit back and listen to the callers as they made their own points.

All but one of the callers was against the idea. I spoke to one of the production people, who told me about a flood of e-mails and text messages that ran 20-1 against. …

Sean says he was particularly grateful to the lady who …

… gave me the point about perfect copies of ID cards on sale in Lagos weeks before the real ones had begun dropping through letter boxes.

He continued:

Quite plainly, the speakers for the scheme were drunk on technology that they didn't understand. None of them could answer the often fierce questioning from the callers about how retina eye scans could be made secure against forgery.

I said less than I normally do. I didn't get properly on to the civil liberties aspects. But it was the callers who made all those points, and with impressive fluency and conviction.

I was unable to hear this programme myself, but it sounds like it went well, doesn't it? Sean is working on a system to have all such broadcasts up at the Libertarian Alliance website.

Good show.